Alright, Kimetsu bros, I want to have some real talk. I wrote a big criticism (review) about kny, and I have two questions for you. Do you trust Gotoge? Do you see Gotoge's hackery? If you think Gotoge is not a hack, then find an answer to these things, please:
>Forgets to add one year to characters' ages (the year that took place during the narrative of the manga)
>Makes UM2 battle 3,5 hours long
>Makes UM2 the strongest and smartest demon, then retcons it to make two weaklings win
>Retcons one whole plotline
>Trashes almost all characters, some even creates directly in the dumpster
>Wants to make Tanjirou a saint, makes him a two-faced liar
>Magically tells Kuwajima that Kaigaku became a demon, so whole UM6 battle in the fortress can happen
>Ressurects all characters only for happiness of fans and tells about it with direct words
>HACKS chapters 201-205 with pure bad writing
>Completely trashes the tone of the story
>Adds unnecessary details that contradict and make worse the manga itself by creating holes in logic or plot
>Makes for itself "pet characters" (The Jesus and the Selfinsert) and now wanks them regularly
>Completely annhilates any agency of the main villain which makes any danger he poses laughable, so the main conflict also becomes laughable
>Makes Tokyo prefecture (2,194 km²) the birthplace of all relevant characters
If you are interested in my reasoning, then welcome to my 60 pages long google document with critical analysis. During past year since the end of kny I was slowly losing my sanity, until I wrote this and had to get meds as an unironic shizo.
Link to my 64 pages long criticism (review): docs.google.com
Kimetsu no Yaiba criticism
Other urls found in this thread:
docs.google.com
myredditvideos.com
twitter.com
>shonen author is a hack and a retard
>people who read his stuff and watch the anime are retarded
Who could've guessed
>fire force reaction image
I love that we both aware of our mental state
>retcons it to make two weaklings win
How so? He isn't even the smartest or strongest demon, otherwise he wouldn't be in the #2 slot
>docs.google.com
jfc, take your meds, dude
>smartest demon
>spent his entire fight against Shinobu eating poison even if he wasn’t sure whether the poison’d be effective
Kny should have unironically been longer. The asspulls and power creep come too fast and there's no build up. You go from generic shit demon to the strongest 12, but 6 of them are fodder, and now end game. I did like that main bad guy got killed for a lot of different reasons and not just mc getting another random boost.
That last chapter really was trash though. How many lines did he snort
>I did like that main bad guy got killed for a lot of different reasons and not just mc getting another random boost.
I just wish four of those reasons weren't O MY ANTI DEMON DRUG
>Douma would need to be smart and cunning in order to hide from the eyes of Ubuyashiki in plain sight for more than a hundred years, being a famous person.
>Douma's control over his blood demon techniques was unrivaled. Chapter 143 even shows how he caught Shinobu with lotus stems as she began to fall. The writhing and moving stems of a lotus made from ice. Ice, by the way, is solid and does not bend. That is, Douma had deliberately guided these stalks of ice, making them wriggle and grow like real plants in a fraction of a second.
>Douma was probably the most powerful Upper Moon for humans, unless he was the most powerful demon against humans. Muzan's poison and tentacles are certainly effective, but Muzan's poison acts slower than an ice cloud, causing immediate lung necrosis, and a whirlwind of ice spikes / fragments can cut people into mince in an instant as well as toothy tentacles. At the same time, Douma himself could sit in an ice capsule or statue, from where it would be impossible to scratch him out. Of course, Douma could not take the place of the Upper Moon One, due to the fact that Kokushibou was a demon, he could cut the ice and, in an instant, heal any damage received, but his blood demon technique was definitely more deadly for people than moon sickles.